Monday, 9 November 2009

Good post from Mississippi Atheists today

Interesting points:

Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (and every off-shoot, sect, denomination, etc.) are each and all founded upon the same ideological mind trap clothed within a commonly asserted divine authority that is beyond contention by virtue of costume, incense, bell ringing and lots of repetitive chanting.

In other words, they are fictional narratives that human beings derive, craft, invent and re-invent to maintain power and authority for better or worse through the concept of ancestral tradition and childhood indoctrination.

The bottom line is that the moderates and liberals of all religious traditions should be taken to task for not being more pro-actively critical of the darker, more violent and absolutist brands of their own religion (cultural narratives) and not just pipe up to critique the criticism when one of their own goes “Old Testament” on folks (as in Fort Hood, Texas, last week).

Some moderates and liberals explain away these violent events by claiming that the “true” interpretations derived from each of these religions is firmly and universally founded upon “love, compassion, caring, empathy and reciprocity”, aka "many flowing rivers leading to one shimmering ocean of understanding", no matter the obvious violence and despair that some adherents promote due to their mythic bonds and purported special relationships with a God who never appears, but is most often just an expression of their own human desires and cravings.

My question for both rigid fundamentalist and liberal mystic continues to be this:

Why do we as a species hold onto these archaic myths, legends and lore to provide us directives on how to love and care for each other in this good life when they are inescapably polluted with the contradictions of brutal deities, prophets and teachers promoting “their way or the highway to Hell”?

Do we not know how to be good without them?

Do we not know how to love without them?

I believe that all humans do, in fact, know the importance of the deep and abiding human values of love, empathy and reciprocity without such primitive religious narratives about burning bushes and assorted winged angels visiting special men walking alone to tell us what a deity beyond space and time thinks about women, other gods, pigs, oysters and foreskins or which tribe is his favorite deserving of a particular patch of desert and a glorious reward in the afterlife magic kingdom.

Given all of the empirical evidence we may currently have to the contrary, however, that claim might just make me the real faithful believer after all.

5 comments:

Steve Borthwick said...

"liberal mystic" I love that;

I detest the whole politically correct idea that all opinions and cultures are equal and that we should give unconditional respect to every crackpot idea that comes along so long as it calls itself "religion" or "faith" or "spirituality". It's all so obviously man made and self serving.

GW said...

I concur, Steve, and further agree that all obviously man made and self serving concepts are equally flawed, as you have suggested elsewhere.

Anonymous said...

You all are sooooo blind!

Elizabeth said...

I don't agree with you, Anonymous, but thanks for adding your opinion.

Steve Borthwick said...

We're probably all dooooomed as well :):)

 
Add to Technorati Favorites expatriate Site Meter cash advance